When is an Ankle Fusion a Better Idea Than an Ankle Replacement?

Ankle arthrodesis or fusion procedures have been around for many years. They were previously considered the gold standard to treat end-stage arthritis of the ankle before ankle replacements were developed and became more reliable and popular.

Although ankle replacements have become much more common, ankle arthrodesis procedures are still a good option to treat arthritis and deformity in the ankle in certain patients. Some of the common reasons we recommend an ankle fusion over replacement are severe valgus deformities of the ankle, neuropathy or lack of feeling in the foot and ankle, Charcot ankle deformity, and severe obesity.

Varus type deformities of the ankle can typically be corrected pretty well with an ankle replacement, but valgus deformities are more difficult for an ankle replacement to really stabilize well. Valgus deformities of the ankle typically present with a flatter foot type and loss of arch height. The valgus deformity is unstable medially over the deltoid ligament, so an ankle fusion can give patients a more stable ankle to walk on and be more reliable long-term than an ankle replacement.

Diabetic Charcot neuroarthropathy also predisposes ankle replacements to fail and subside and typically the bone quality is not as strong to accept the ankle replacement well. We typically recommend ankle fusions in these cases as well to try to make the hindfoot and ankle more stable for patients to walk on.

Specialized, custom braces called ankle-foot orthoses (AFO) can be utilized to try to stabilize the hindfoot and ankle to avoid surgery. If this does not work and patients still have pain with the brace, ankle and hindfoot fusions can sometimes be helpful.

If you are having any foot and ankle pain, call our expert Colorado Springs foot and ankle surgeons today at 719-488-4664. Dr. Hinderland, Dr. Cameron, and Dr. Dominick are all part of our team at Foot and Ankle Institute of Colorado, to help keep you active and on your feet!

Dr. Matthew Hinderland Board Certified Podiatrist and Foot and Ankle Surgeon

You Might Also Enjoy...

Can an Ankle Sprain Simply Heal with Rest?

While popular opinion states that sprained ankles can only be left to heal on their own, that can actually lead to complications and prolonged healing. We review why you should seek medical treatment for your sprained ankle here.

Do I Need Surgery for My Hammertoe?

If you have a hammertoe, you might be wondering if surgery is your only option to treat it. We explore all your treatment options for hammertoe here and review when surgery becomes necessary.

How Are Custom Orthotics Made?

If you suffer from chronic foot and ankle pain, you might need custom-made orthotics. Find out more about the process of making custom orthotics here.

Can My Ingrown Toenail Heal on Its Own?

If you struggle with ingrown toenails — a common foot condition — you might be wondering if they’ll go away all on their own, or if you always need to seek treatment for them. We review that and more here.

I Have High Arches. Now What?

If you have high arches, you’re at risk for developing other foot health issues. Read on to learn how to treat any potential complications of high arches and more about this foot condition.

What’s Behind Your Popping Ankles?

Ankle popping is common. But how do you know what’s causing it, and if it’s something you should be worried about? We answer those questions and more here.